Can poultry gelatin substitute bovine gelatin? : a systematic review and meta-analysis

Moh Taufik; Nurwulan Purnasari; ‪Ilzamha Hadijah Rusdan; Frendy Ahmad Afandi; Mojiono Mojiono; Yoni Atma

doi:10.21107/agrointek.v18i3.18051

Can poultry gelatin substitute bovine gelatin? : a systematic review and meta-analysis

Moh Taufik, Nurwulan Purnasari, ‪Ilzamha Hadijah Rusdan, Frendy Ahmad Afandi, Mojiono Mojiono, Yoni Atma

Abstract

Gelatin is one of the popular ingredients and additives in food industries. They have been applied in various roles, including stabilizers, thickeners, and emulsifiers. Bovine (cattle or cow) is one of the most widely used a source of gelatin. Unfortunately, they are still limited in particular considerations. For example, bovine gelatin is unacceptable in some Hindu communities. And the risks of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) contamination, spreading, and outbreak related to bovine as a source. To challenge these limitations, poultry is another promising source. Current studies have found a similarity between poultry or chicken-based gelatin and bovine gelatin. However, investigation on the comparability of their gel strength is still rare. It is generally accepted that gel strength is the most essential characteristic of gelatin. This systematic review examined the gel strength between poultry gelatin and bovine gelatin. There were 795 papers screened, 29 full-text papers assessed, and 10 papers reviewed. The meta-analysis shows that chicken feet (CFG) and head (CHG) gelatin possessed a higher gel strength value than bovine gelatin. In contrast, the gel strength of chicken skin gelatin (CSG) and bovine gelatin did not differ significantly. The meta-analysis demonstrates that the gel strength of duck feet (DFG) and skin (DSG) gelatin is comparable with bovine gelatin. Thus, this study exposed the feasibility of CSG, DFG, and DSG, which can be the substitute for bovine gelatin.

Keywords

bovine gelatin; chicken gelatin; duck gelatin; gel strength; poultry gelatin;

Full Text:

PDF

References

Abdullah, M.S.P., Noordin, M.I., Nyamathulla, S., Ismail, S.I.M., Jasamai, M., Wai, L.K., Mustapha, N.M.,and Shamsuddin, A.F. 2016. Physicochemical evaluation and spectroscopic characterisation of gelatine from shank and toes of Gallus gallus domesticus. Sains Malaysiana 45(3): 435–449.

Afandi, F.A. 2020. Meta-Analisis Faktor-Faktor Penentu Nilai Indeks Glikemik Bahan Pangan Pati-Patian Dan Verifikasinya Dengan Menggunakan Model Pangan. Disertasi Institut Pertanian Bogor, Bogor.

Afandi, F.A., Wijaya, C.H., Faridah, D.N., Suyatma, N.E., and Jayanegara, A. 2021. Evaluation of various starchy foods: A systematic review and meta-analysis on chemical properties affecting the glycemic index values based on in vitro and in vivo experiments. Foods. 10(2): 364.

Ahmad, M., and Benjakul, S. 2011. Characteristics of gelatin from the skin of unicorn leatherjacket (Aluterus monoceros) as influenced by acid pretreatment and extraction time. Food Hydrocolloids. 25(3): 381–388.

Al-Hassan, A.A. 2020. Gelatin from camel skins: Extraction and characterizations. Food Hydrocolloids. 101: 105457.

Alipal, J., Mohd Pu’ad, N.A.S., Lee, T.C., Nayan, N.H.M., Sahari, N., Basri, H., Idris, M.I., and Abdullah, H.Z. 2021. A review of gelatin: Properties, sources, process, applications, and commercialisation. Materials Today: Proceedings. 42: 240–250.

Almeida, P.F.D, Reinaldo, J., and Caetano, S. 2013. Quality assurance and economical feasibility of an innovative product obtained from a byproduct of the meat industry in Brazil. African Journal of Business Management. 7(27), 2745–2756.

Ardekani, V.S., Mahmoodani, F., See, S.F., Yusop, S.M., and Babji, A.S. 2013. Processing optimization and characterization of gelatin from catfish (Clarias gariepinus) skin. Sains Malaysiana. 42(12): 1697–1705.

Aykın-Dincer, E., Koc, A., and Erbas, M. 2017. Extraction and physicochemical characterization of broiler (Gallus gallus domesticus) skin gelatin compared to commercial bovine gelatin. Poultry Science. 96(11): 4124–4131.

Azilawati, M.I., Hashim, D.M., Jamilah, B., and Amin, I. 2015. RP-HPLC method using 6-aminoquinolyl-N-hydroxysuccinimidyl carbamate incorporated with normalization technique in principal component analysis to differentiate the bovine, porcine and fish gelatins. Food Chemistry. 172: 368–376.

Bichukale, A.D. 2018. Functional Properties of Gelatin Extracted From Poultry Skin and Bone Waste. International Journal of Pure & Applied Bioscience. 6(4): 87–101.

Blagushina, N., Diachkova, E., Volkova, M., Pankush, S. and Tarasenko, S. 2020. Comparative Analysis of the Use of Domestic Bioresorbable Collagen Membranes at the Closure of Postoperative Defects of the Oral Mucosa in an Experiment In vivo. Biointerface Res. Appl. Chem. 11, 9804 - 9812

Chakka, A.K., Muhammed, A., Sakhare, P.Z., and Bhaskar, N. 2017. Poultry Processing Waste as an Alternative Source for Mammalian Gelatin: Extraction and Characterization of Gelatin from Chicken Feet Using Food Grade Acids. Waste and Biomass Valorization. 8(8): 2583–2593.

Chettupalli, A.K., Ananthula, M., Amarachinta, P.R., Bakshi, V., and Yata, V.K. 2021. Design, Formulation, in-vitro and ex-vivo evaluation of atazanavir loaded cubosomal gel. Biointerface Res. Appl. Chem. 11(4): 12037-12054.

Dara, P.K., Raghavankutty, M., Sebastian, N., Chatterjee, N.S., Mathew, S., Ravishankar, C.N., and Anandan, R. 2020. Rheological, Physico-chemical, and Surface-Active Properties of Gelatin Extracted from Bigeye Tuna (Thunnus obesus) Skin Waste. Journal of Aquatic Food Product Technology. 29(5): 428–444.

Ee, S.C., Saari, N., Abas, F., Ismail, A., Bakar, M.K.A, and Bakar, J. 2019. Properties of chicken head gelatins as affected by extraction method. International Food Research Journal. 26(2): 499–508.

El Blidi, O., El Omari, N., Balahbib, A., Ghchime, R., El Menyiy, N., Ibrahimi, A., Ben Kaddour, K., Bouyahya, A., Chokairi, O. and Barkiyou, M. 2021. Extraction methods, characterization and biomedical applications of collagen: a review. Biointerface Res. Appl. Chem. 11, 13587-13613.

Elsanat, S.Y., Korish, M.A., & Ammar, A K. 2014. Optimizing The Extraction Conditions of Gelatin Obtained from Chicken Processing By- Products. Alex. J. Fd. Sci.&Technol. 1(1): 1–9.

Erge, A., and Zorba, Ö. 2018. Optimization of gelatin extraction from chicken mechanically deboned meat residue using alkaline pre-treatment. Lwt. 97: 205–212.

Gál, R., Mokrejš, P., Mrázek, P., Pavlačková, J., Janáčová, D., and Orsavová, J. 2020. Chicken heads as a promising by-product for preparation of food gelatins. Molecules. 25(3): 494

Gómez-Estaca, J., Montero, P., Fernández-Martín, F., and Gómez-Guillén, M.C. 2009. Physico-chemical and film-forming properties of bovine-hide and tuna-skin gelatin: A comparative study. Journal of Food Engineering. 90(4): 480–486.

Gomez-Guillen, M.C., Gimenez, B., Lopez-Caballero, M.E., and Montero, M.P. 2011. Functional and bioactive properties of collagen and gelatin from alternative sources: A review. Food Hydrocolloids. 25(8): 1813–1827.

Gomez-Guillen, M.C., Turnay, J., Fernandez-Dõaz, M.D., Ulmo, N., Lizarbe, M. A., and Montero, P. 2002. Structural and physical properties of gelatin extracted from different marine species: a comparative study. Food Hydrocolloids. 16(1): 25–34.

Gündem, A., and Tarhan, Ö. 2020. Bulletin of Biotechnology Extraction of collagen and gelatine from animal wastes. In REVIEW ARTICLE Bull Biotechnol. 1(1):30-33.

Haidich, A. 2010. Meta-analysis in medical research. Hippokratia. 1(14): 29–37.

Hanani, Z.A.N. 2016. Gelatin. Encyclopedia of Food and Health, 191-195, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-384947-2.00347-0.

Haug, I.J., Draget, K.I., and Smidsrød, O. 2004. Physical and rheological properties of fish gelatin compared to mammalian gelatin. Food Hydrocolloids. 18(2): 203–213.

Herpandi, Huda, H., and Adzitey, F. 2011. Fish Bone and Scale as a Potensial Source of Halal Gelatin. Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science. 6(4): 379–389.

Hutapea, T.P.H., Rukisah, Muliyadi, Madurani, K.A., Suprapto, and Kurniawan, F. 2020. Chemistry and Physic Characterization of Milkfish (Chanos chanos) Gelatin from Tarakan, North Borneo, Indonesia. E3S Web of Conferences. 153: 12–15.

Jongjareonrak, A., Benjakul, S., Visessanguan, W., Nagai, T., and Tanaka, M. 2005. Isolation and characterisation of acid and pepsin-solubilised collagens from the skin of Brownstripe red snapper (Lutjanus vitta). Food Chemistry. 93(3): 475–484.

Kadir, A.A.A.K., Huda, N., Zakaria, Z.Z., Bakar, C.A.A., and Shahidan, N.S. 2020. Physicochemical properties of duck (Khaki Campbell) skin gelatin pre-treated with acetic acid and citric acid. Utilization of Biodiversity for the Greater Benefit of Mankind. 70–77.

Karim, A.A., and Bhat, R. 2009. Fish gelatin: properties, challenges, and prospects as an alternative to mammalian gelatins. Food Hydrocolloids. 23(2): 563–576.

Khirzin, M.H., Ton, S., and Fatkhurrohman, F. 2019. Ekstraksi dan Karakterisasi Gelatin Tulang Itik Menggunakan Metode Ekstraksi Asam. Jurnal Sain Peternakan Indonesia. 14(2): 119–127.

Kuan, Y.H., Nafchi, A.M., Huda, N., Ariffin, F., and Karim, A.A. 2016. Comparison of physicochemical and functional properties of duck feet and bovine gelatins. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. 97(5): 1663–1671.

Lu, Y., Luo, Q., Chu, Y., Tao, N., Deng, S., Wang, L., and Li, L. 2022. Application of Gelatin in Food Packaging: A Review. Polymers, 14(3): 436

Lueyot, A., Rungsardthong, V., Vatanyoopaisarn, S., Hutangura, P., Wonganu, B., Wongsa-Ngasri, P., Charoenlappanit, S., Roytrakul, S., & Thumthanaruk, B. 2021. Influence of collagen and some proteins on gel properties of jellyfish gelatin. PLoS ONE. 16: 1–14.

Mirzapour-Kouhdasht, A., Moosavi-Nasab, M., Lee, C. W., Yun, H., and Eun, J. B. 2021. Structure–function engineering of novel fish gelatin-derived multifunctional peptides using high-resolution peptidomics and bioinformatics. Scientific Reports. 11(1): 1–15.

Miskiyah, M., Sasmitaloka, K.S., Kamsiati, E., Juniawati, J., and Budiyanto, A. 2020. Karakteristik Mutu Gelatin Ceker Ayam Sebagai Alternatif Gelatin Halal. Jurnal Standardisasi. 22(3): 239.

Mokrejš, P., Mrázek, P., Gál, R., and Pavlačková, J. 2019. Biotechnological preparation of gelatines from chicken feet. Polymers. 11(6): 1060.

Mrázek, P., Mokrejš, P., Gál, R., and Orsavová, J. (2019). Chicken skin gelatine as an alternative to pork and beef gelatines. Potravinarstvo Slovak Journal of Food Sciences. 13(1): 224–233.

Muhammad, N.A.N., Huda, N., Karim, A.A., and Mohammadi Nafchi, A. 2018. Effects of acid type extraction on characterization and sensory profile of duck feet gelatin: towards finding bovine gelatin alternative. Journal of Food Measurement and Characterization. 12(1): 480–486.

Mustami, K., Ahmad, A., Ismail, A., and Hamzah, N. 2020. Improving Quality of Halal Milkfish Gelatin by Cross-Link with Sucrose and Glutaradehid. AICIS

Muyonga, J.H., Cole, C.G.B., and Duodu, K.G. 2004. Extraction and physico-chemical characterisation of Nile perch (Lates niloticus) skin and bone gelatin. Food Hydrocolloids. 18(4): 581–592.

Nagarajan, M., Benjakul, S., Prodpran, T., Songtipya, P., and Kishimura, H. 2012. Characteristics and functional properties of gelatin from splendid squid (Loligo formosana) skin as affected by extraction temperatures. Food Hydrocolloids. 29(2): 389–397.

Nitsuwat, S., Zhang, P., Ng, K., and Fang, Z. 2021. Fish gelatin as an alternative to mammalian gelatin for food industry: A meta-analysis. Lwt. 141: 110899.

Noor, N.Q.I.M., Razali, R.S., Ismail, N.K., Ramli, R.A., Razali, U.H.M., Bahauddin, A.R., Zaharudin, N., Rozzamri, A., Bakar, J., and Shaarani, S.M. 2021. Application of green technology in gelatin extraction: A review. Processes. 9(12): 2227

Nur Azira, T., Che Man, Y.B., Raja Mohd Hafidz, R.N., Aina, M.A., and Amin, I. 2014. Use of principal component analysis for differentiation of gelatine sources based on polypeptide molecular weights. Food Chemistry. 151: 286–292.

Park, J.H., Choe, J.H., Kim, H.W., Hwang, K.E., Song, D.H., Yeo, E.J., Kim, H.Y., Choi, Y.S., Lee, S. H., and Kim, C.J. 2013. Effects of various extraction methods on quality characteristics of duck feet gelatin. Korean Journal for Food Science of Animal Resources. 33(2): 162–169.

Rafieian, F., Keramat, J., and Kadivar, M. 2013. Optimization of gelatin extraction from chicken deboner residue using RSM method. Journal of Food Science and Technology. 50(2): 374–380.

Rafieian, F., Keramat, J., and Shahedi, M. 2015. Physicochemical properties of gelatin extracted from chicken deboner residue. LWT - Food Science and Technology. 64(2): 1370–1375.

Rahim, A.H., Ahmad, H., and Rahim, A.M.H. 2021. Extraction of Gelatin from Different Parts of Gallus Gallus Domesticus. Current Science and Technology. 1(1): 50–55.

Rahman, M.N.A., and Jamalulail, S.A.S.K.A. 2013. Extractions, Physicochemical Characterizations And Sensory Quality Of Chicken Feet Gelatin. Borneo Science. 33–43.

Rasli, H.I., and Sarbon, N.M. 2015. Effects of different drying methods on the rheological, functional and structural properties of chicken skin gelatin compared to bovine gelatin. In International Food Research Journal. 22(2): 584-592.

Regenstein, J.M., Chaudry, M.M., and Regenstein, C.E. 2003. The Kosher and Halal Food Laws. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 2(3): 111–127.

ReportLinker. 2022. Global Gelatin Industry. Available online: https://www.reportlinker.com/p05478473/Global-Gelatin-Industry.html (accessed: 16 February 2022).

Saenmuang, S., Phothiset, S., and Chumnanka, C. 2020. Extraction and characterization of gelatin from black-bone chicken by-products. Food Science and Biotechnology. 29(4): 469–478.

Sahilah, A.M., Fadly, M.L., Norrakiah, A.S., Aminah, A., Wan Aida, W., Ma’aruf, A.G., and Khan, M.A. 2012. Halal market surveillance of soft and hard gel capsules in pharmaceutical products using PCR and southern-hybridization on the biochip analysis. International Food Research Journal. 19(1): 371–375.

Samsudin, F.S., Aminal, N., Arina, F., and Zain, M. 2018. Physicochemical Properties of Quail Bone Gelatin Extract with Hydrochloric Acid and Citric Acid. Journal Of Agrobiotechnology. 9(1S): 92–101.

Santana, J.C.C., Almeida, P.F., Costa, N., Vasconcelos, I., Guerhardt, F., Boukouvalas, D.T., Alves, W.A.L., Mendoza, P.C., Gamarra, F.M.C., Llanos, S.A.V., Araujo, S.A., Quispe, A.P.B., Vanalle, R.M., and Berssaneti, F.T. 2021. Combination of computational techniques to obtain high-quality gelatin-base gels from chicken feet. Polymers. 13(8): 1289

Sarbon, M.N., Badii, F., and Howell, N.K. 2013. Preparation and characterisation of chicken skin gelatin as an alternative to mammalian gelatin. Food Hydrocolloids. 30(1): 143–151.

Schrieber, R., and Gareis, H. 2007. Gelatine Handbook Theory and Industrial Practice.

Shabani, H., Mehdizadeh, M., Mousavi, S.M., Dezfouli, E.A., Solgi, T., Khodaverdi, M., Rabiei, M., Rastegar, H., and Alebouyeh, M. 2015. Halal authenticity of gelatin using species-specific PCR. Food Chemistry. 184: 203–206.

Siburian, W.Z., Rochima, E., Andriani, Y., and Praseptiangga, D. 2020. International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies 2020; 8(4): 90-95 Fish gelatin (definition, manufacture, analysis of quality characteristics, and application): A review. International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies. 8(4): 90–95.

Sousa, S.C., Vázquez, J.A., Pérez-Martín, R.I., Carvalho, A.P., and Gomes, A.M. 2017. Valorization of by-products from commercial fish species: Extraction and chemical properties of skin gelatins. Molecules. 22(9): 1545

Suderman, N., Isa, M.I.N., and Sarbon, N.M. 2018. Characterization on the mechanical and physical properties of chicken skin gelatin films in comparison to mammalian gelatin films. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering. 440(1).

Teng, N.Y., Huda, N., Mohd Shariff, A.H., Nafchi, A.M., & Zakaria, Z. 2021. Physicochemical Properties of Peking Duck Skin Gelatin Extracted Using Acid Pretreatment (ADS) or Mixed Alkaline-Acid Pretreatment (ALDS). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. 709(1).

Valcarcel, J., Fraguas, J., Hermida-Merino, C., Hermida-Merino, D., Piñeiro, M.M., & Vázquez, J.A. 2021. Production and physicochemical characterization of gelatin and collagen hydrolysates from turbot skin waste generated by aquaculture activities. Marine Drugs. 19(9): 491.

Statista. 2017. Distribution share of the gelatin market worldwide in 2016 by type of raw material, Available online: https://www.statista.com/statistics/712112/distribution-gelatin-market-worldwide/ (accessed: 16 February 2022).

Xin, Y., Chai, M., Chen, F., Hou, Y., Lai, S., and Yang, H. 2021. Comparative study on the gel properties and nanostructures of gelatins from chicken, porcine, and tilapia skin. Journal of Food Science. 86(5): 1936–1945.

Yuswan, M.H., Nurul, N.H., Mohamad, H., Keso, S., Mohamad, N.A., Tengku, T. S., Ismail, N.F., Abdul Manaf, Y.N., Mohd Hashim, A., Mohd Desa, M.N., Yusof, Y.A., and Mustafa, S. 2021. Hydroxyproline determination for initial detection of halal-critical food ingredients (gelatin and collagen). Food Chemistry, 337:127762

Zain, F.A.M., Shahidan, N., Huda, N., Zakaria, Z., and Septama, A.W. 2020. Physichochemical properties of Khaki Campbell , Muscovy and Pekin duck feet gelatin extracted with acetic acid. Utilization of Biodiversity for the Greater Benefit of Mankind. 67–74.

Zhang, W., Chen, C., Huang, Z., and Wang, P. 2021. Characterizations of gelatin from the skin of american bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) as affected by extraction temperature. Sustainability. 13(8): 4390

Zin, Z.M., Sarbon, N.M., Zainol, M.K., Nur’, S., Jaafar, A., Shukri, M.M., Hj, A., and Rahman, A. 2021. Halal and Non-Halal Gelatine as a Potential Animal By-Products in Food Systems: Prospects and Challenges for Muslim Community.