Kajian meta-analisis pengaruh metode penyembelihan terhadap kualitas daging ruminansia

Yuli Maulidiyah; Feri Kusnandar; Hanifah Nuryani Lioe; Anuraga Jayanegara

doi:10.21107/agrointek.v19i2.25242

Kajian meta-analisis pengaruh metode penyembelihan terhadap kualitas daging ruminansia

Yuli Maulidiyah, Feri Kusnandar, Hanifah Nuryani Lioe, Anuraga Jayanegara

Abstract

Meats of consumable livestock for humans are commonly from ruminants, such as cows, goats, lambs, buffaloes, etc. The method of slaughtering the livestock at the slaughterhouse mostly applies non-stunning or stunning methods. The stunning method uses electricity, mechanics, and gas. The slaughtering methods influence the meat quality and results. Thus, further meta-analysis is important to provide valid and informative conclusions based on comprehensive investigations about the slaughtering method's effect on ruminant meat quality. The researchers applied the PRISMA diagram and the size of the Standard Mean Difference effect, SMD, with Hedge's formulation as the quantitative synthetical meta-analysis method. The results found that the slaughtering method with stunning and non-stunning methods did not significantly influence some parameters, such as pH, colors (L*, a*, and b*), the water holding capacity, cooking loss, and shear force. However, the methods significantly influenced the drip loss and myofibril fragmentation index parameters with SMD values <0.2, p-values <0.001 to 0.777, and heterogeneity values of 0% to 82.98%.

Keywords

Meat quality; Ruminansia; Slaughter method;

Full Text:

PDF (Bahasa Indonesia)

References

Aghwan, Z. A., A. U. Bello, A. A. Abubakar, J. C. Imlan, and A. Q. Sazili. 2016. Efficient halal bleeding, animal handling, and welfare: A holistic approach for meat quality. Meat Science 121:420–428.

Agung Hidayat, M., K. Kuswati, and T. Susilawati. 2015. Pengaruh lama istirahat terhadap karakteristik karkas dan kualitas fisik daging sapi Brahman Cross Steer. Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Peternakan 25(2):71–79.

Bourguet, C., V. Deiss, C. C. Tannugi, and E. M. C. Terlouw. 2011. Behavioural and physiological reactions of cattle in a commercial abattoir: Relationships with organisational aspects of the abattoir and animal characteristics. Meat Science 88(1):158–168.

Büyükünal, S. K., and B. Nazli. 2007. Effect of different electrical stunning methods on meat quality of marmara Kivircik breed lamb in Turkey Republic. Veterinarski glasnik 61(3–4):155–162.

Gurevitch, J., J. Koricheva, S. Nakagawa, and G. Stewart. 2018. Meta-analysis and the science of research synthesis. Nature 555(7695):175–182.

Gustiani, E. 2009. Pengendalian cemaran mikroba pada bahan pangan asal ternak ( daging dan susu) mulai dari peternakan sampai dihidangkan. Jurnal Litbang Pertanian 28(3):96–100.

Hopkins, D. L., P. J. Littlefield, and J. M. Thompson. 2000. A research note on factors affecting the determination of myofibrillar fragmentation. Meat Science 56(1):19–22.

Koricheva, J., J. Gurevitch, and K. Mengersen. 2013. Handbook of meta-analysis in ecology and evolution. Page Handbook of Meta-analysis in Ecology and Evolution.

Linares, M. B., R. Bórnez, and H. Vergara. 2007. Effect of different stunning systems on meat quality of light lamb. Meat Science 76(4):675–681.

Lokman, N. S., A. B. Sabow, A. A. Abubakar, K. D. Adeyemi, and A. Q. Sazili. 2017. Comparación del cuerpo y la calidad de la carne en cabras sujetas a aturdimiento eléctrico limitado a la cabeza previo a la matanza o sin aturdimiento eléctrico. CYTA - Journal of Food 15(1):99–104.

Mačanga, J., B. Koréneková, J. Nagy, S. Marcinčák, P. Popelka, I. Kožárová, and M. Korének. 2011. Post-mortem changes in the concentration of lactic acid, phosphates and pH in the muscles of wild rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) according to the perimortal situation. Meat Science 88(4):701–704.

Mahmudah, K., F. Fitrianingsih, and A. Bain. 2022. Susut Masak, Daya Ikat Air dan Kadar Protein Daging Ayam Broiler yang Diberi Pakan Mengandung Tepung Ikan. Jurnal Ilmiah Peternakan Halu Oleo 4(3):214.

Mir, N. A., A. Rafiq, F. Kumar, V. Singh, and V. Shukla. 2017. Determinants of broiler chicken meat quality and factors affecting them: a review. Journal of Food Science and Technology 54(10):2997–3009.

Modzelewska-Kapituła, M., A. Kwiatkowska, B. Jankowska, and E. Dabrowska. 2015. Water holding capacity and collagen profile of bovine m. infraspinatus during postmortem ageing. Meat Science 100:209–216.

Mortimer, S. I., J. H. J. van der Werf, R. H. Jacob, D. L. Hopkins, L. Pannier, K. L. Pearce, G. E. Gardner, R. D. Warner, G. H. Geesink, J. E. Hocking Edwards, E. N. Ponnampalam, A. J. Ball, A. R. Gilmour, and D. W. Pethick. 2014. Genetic parameters for meat quality traits of Australian lamb meat. Meat Science 96(2):1016–1024.

Önenç, A., and A. Kaya. 2004. The effects of electrical stunning and percussive captive bolt stunning on meat quality of cattle processed by Turkish slaughter procedures. Meat Science 66(4):809–815.

Palupi, E., A. Jayanegara, A. Ploeger, and J. Kahl. 2012. Comparison of nutritional quality between conventional and organic dairy products: A meta-analysis. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 92(14):2774–2781.

Rosenvold, K., and H. J. Andersen. 2003. Factors of significance for pork quality - A review. Meat Science 64(3):219–237.

Sabow, A. B., K. D. Adeyemi, Z. Idrus, G. Y. Meng, M. Z. A. Ab Kadir, U. Kaka, Z. A. Aghwan, A. A. Abubakar, and A. Q. Sazili. 2017. Carcase characteristics and meat quality assessments in goats subjected to slaughter without stunning and slaughter following different methods of electrical stunning. Italian Journal of Animal Science 16(3):416–430.

Sabow, A. B., A. Q. Sazili, I. Zulkifli, Y. M. Goh, M. Z. A. Ab Kadir, N. R. Abdulla, K. Nakyinsige, U. Kaka, and K. D. Adeyemi. 2015. A comparison of bleeding efficiency, microbiological quality and lipid oxidation in goats subjected to conscious halal slaughter and slaughter following minimal anesthesia. Meat Science 104:78–84.

Soeparno. 2005. Ilmu dan Teknologi Daging. Cetakan keempat. Gajah Mada University Press, Yogyakarta.

Velarde, A., M. Gispert, A. Diestre, and X. Manteca. 2003. Effect of electrical stunning on meat and carcass quality in lambs. Page Meat Science.

Vergara, H., and L. Gallego. 2000. Effect of electrical stunning on meat quality of lamb. Page Meat Science.

Vergara, H., M. B. Linares, M. I. Berruga, and L. Gallego. 2005. Meat quality in suckling lambs: Effect of pre-slaughter handling. Meat Science 69(3):473–478.